TW/Trigger Warning: homophobia/transphobia.
When it came to murder, Soup was the last boy that the dull town of Sallisaw, Wyoming would ever accuse. Granted, his name wasn’t actually Soup. Soup’s full name was Campbell John Frankinson (the third), but everyone just called him Soup. Campbell was his father. His father was a soup: A chunky, slightly unpleasant, microwaved last-choice of sustenance. Campbell was not a soup. He was a bright boy, an odd boy, a boy that would not stand out in your mind if he didn’t have an odd name. So, Soup was Soup.
Soup had two friends. His longest friend was Jared Wilkins. He lived across the street in the pale yellow barn house--the one with blue shutters--since 2002. He was gangly and too thin to use his heights for any social advantage. Then there was Jillian Meyers. Jillian was added to Jared and Soup’s group in 2016 when she was ostracized from the whole school. She unknowingly committed social suicide when she came out as transgender, small conservative town and all. Nonetheless, Jillian found a home in Jared and Soup. Mrs. Frankinson was so happy that Campbell had another friend that she gave Jillian the hand-me-downs from Cousin Claire that were supposed to go to his little sister, Jane.
They rode bikes across town like a John Hughes film. Sometimes, Jane would ride on Soup’s handlebars if she wanted to ride with them to the convenience store ten minutes away. She’d walk home on her own with a warm candy bar in her pocket and content showing on her face. It was an arrangement that was allowed by his mom, as long as everyone got home before dark. Mrs. Frankinson forced Soup to get his driver’s license when he turned seventeen, despite his bicyclar mobility, to be able to help out with driving around Jane. She said it was to help keep him safe in case it rained and was unsafe to ride to school, but Soup also knew the sudden
Soup was a decent boy in school. He was riding the average line, no higher or lower. He skimmed just under the radar, a skill that one could only admire from afar. He didn’t mind this trait of his. In fact, Soup seemed to prefer it. He was never bullied, never pulled apart from the rest. He was never first to be picked on the sports teams for P.E., but also not the last. He was grouped into projects without any fuss or contemplation, fitting into the rest like he was a perfectly designed puzzle piece. He didn’t complete the picture, but he helped bring it along. Everyone just knew him as Soup. No other characteristics clung to him.Soup introduced himself and Soup he was.
It was on September 22nd, 2010 that Jillian showed up at Soup’s door. She was flushed and breathless, her chest heaving with deep breaths. Together they ran to Jared’s door, banging and shouting until Mr. Wilkins opened the door with a disgruntled puff of smoke in their faces and Jared slinked out the door. Jillian pulled her jacket tighter around herself; the fall air was beginning to settle in their bones.
“I have a date,” she breathed out, as if she had been holding the breath of truth in for weeks.
Jared and Soup didn’t know what to say, didn’t know what to do.
“Dude, that’s so fuckin’ awesome,” Jared said. Soup stayed quiet, but his smile was confirmation enough of his feelings.
“Who’s the lucky dude?”
“His name is Dillon, the boy from my Biology class I had been telling you guys about,” Jillian said. Her eyes sparkled like in the books. Life had been hard for Jillian Meyers. If it hadn’t been for Jared and Soup, who knows where Jillian would be right now. Probably six feet under if we’re being honest. With a father who doesn’t support her, a mother who still calls her Matthew, and a school who can’t look at her without a sneer and a whisper, a date is more than just exciting.
Mrs. Frankinson helped Jillian get ready the following Friday. They were going to see Devil, the new horror movie that had come out (because nothing screamed “high school first date” like a poorly rated horror movie). Dillon was borrowing his dad’s 2005 Dodge Dakota and the boys watched with Mrs. Frankinson as Jillian climbed into the passenger’s seat of the truck. Dillon didn’t come to the door. Soup clenched his jaw.
Jared and Soup were watching Star Wars: Return of the Jedi for the 24th time when Jillian called. Jillian never calls. Jillian only lives a couple streets away. Jillian always rings the doorbell three times in quick succession. Jillian never calls.
Jared answered his phone as quickly as it rang, Soup immediately rushing to his side. He could hear Jillian sobbing into Jared’s ear. He grabbed the keys from the hook on the wall. His mother looked at him in question, but the anger on his face silenced her.
Soup does not get angry.
It was a twenty three minute drive and they made it in seventeen. Jillian was sitting on the curb in front of some houses, a couple meters away from a little park. Jared held her as she sobbed, mascara running down her flushed face. Soup gripped the keys so hard they cut into his palms. Jillian hiccuped the whole way home, Jared sitting with her in the backseat. Mrs. Frankinson was waiting at the kitchen table when they came home, rushing up to grab her and clutch her to her chest. No one, except Jillian, cared that she got makeup marks and tear stains all over their shirts.
Jillian slept over that night. Soup took the couch after forcing his sob-wracked friend into his twin bed. Jared stayed until he was falling asleep, having called his father earlier to explain why he was going to be home so late. They held her as she told them about her night, how Dillon had been perfectly fine until after the movie. He held the door, he bought her ticket, he even held her hand. After the movie, he took her to the neighborhood park to finish their snacks and their conversations. The lights had been turned off and had barely cooled down before he pushed himself onto Jillian, grabbing at her borrowed top and thrusting it off. She pleaded against him and tried to fight him off, but he was larger, much stronger than Jillian. He called her a freak, said no one else would want her but him when she denied.
Dillon apparently had been dared to go out with “the freak” and had obliged. Dillon thought that he could get some good things out of it, that Jillian would feel “blessed enough” to give him something in return. Jared didn’t comment on the bruises on her chest and neck and Soup didn’t either.
Soup did not hate anyone before Dillon Johnson.
Jillian didn’t go to school that Monday, or that Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, or Friday. Soup was silent as he heard people snicker. People would ask him about his “freak friend” and he wouldn't reply. Jared would shout and curse, but people just laughed and walked away.
“People are cruel,” Soup said to Jared at lunch on Thursday after Olivia Sumners, the nice girl from their math class, made a snide comment to him about it being better now that the freak was gone.
“It’s not fair,” Jared said back. Soup could tell he wanted to cry. Jared balled his fists and breathed deeply. His voice wavered, “She’s one of the kindest people I know.”
“I know, Jared, I know.”
At the end of the semester, in honor of winter break, Alex Martinez decided to host a house party in celebration of exams being over. Soup, being who he was, was of course invited. The party was bland, full of mostly empty bottles and practically full cups littered about with no labels. People were too drunk and too loud. Some were compensating, some puking off the balcony.
Vomit froze before it hit the ground. It was that kind of winter night. Despite the bitter cold, Soup found himself on the back patio anyways. He flitted among the smokers, declining offer after offer to keep to himself. He held a solo cup filled with water in his gloved hands, branding himself with a thick, sharpied “SOUP”.
Soup shimmied out into the crowded hallway from the restroom. He was thinking about leaving-- it was already nearing midnight and the stench of puke was beginning to nauseate-- when he heard a quite loud, drunken, and boisterous story being told from behind.
“...n’then was so trying to get into my pants, the whore, suck my dick or somethin’. S’happy to have someone take ‘em out onna date that s’was ready to give it up to anyone. He was beggin’ me and grabbin’ at me and I even had to push ‘em off’a me.”
The narrative belonged to a boy that seemed quite familiar to Soup, probably from a class or two. His slurred words hinted at the couple drinks he had before the one in his hand. Soup dismissed it, turning to walk away from the boasting dickwad before he heard the last name he wanted to hear:
“Always thought that Jillian was a freak, like obvi, but it turns out he’s freakier than I thought.”
The cheap plastic cup splintered in Soup’s fist. Water dribbled down his hand and soaked his cuff, but he didn’t care. He walked up to the boy and for the first time, Soup was not Soup.
“Don’t you say another thing about Jillian,” he said. His voice was low and the girls around the boy, to which he now recognized was Dillon Johnson himself, quieted. Dillon was silent himself for a moment, jaw slack and eyes glazed. The drunk boy started laughing, his drink sloshing onto the floor.
“Are you friends with him?” he laughed, coughing and spitting, “God, he’s a fuckin’ freak.”
“Stop it,” Soup said. The girls to the side stopped talking completely, staring in rapt attention at what was unfolding. One girl whispered to her friend, asking if they should stop Dillon. Another girl walked away with a roll of her eyes.
“God, he’s a fuckin’ fag. A fuckin’ freak, I’m tellin’ you. Pretendin’ he’s a chick n’all.”
“Stop it.”
“She was so lucky to have me. No one would ever fuckin’ want to fuck somethin’ that ugly. He knew it too. That’s why she wanted me so bad, tried so hard.”
“Stop it,” Soup said again, stepping up towards Dillon as the drunken boy stood from the couch to shout in his face. The crowd around had turned into a dull buzz. Soup didn’t know if it was the party going silent or if he was just so angry that he could only focus on the bastard’s beer soaked spittle.
“Maybe next time,” he sways, blinking heavy, drunk, “That little freak will finally let me see what’s really under her skirt.”
The next part of this story will never be said by Soup himself. He doesn’t remember, you see. The only accounts we have are of sobbing and mostly drunk teenagers. Soup, the boy that he was, in an irrational (or rational, whatever your opinion on the story is) thought, grabbed the nearest thing to him and swung. This unfortunately happened to be Mr. Martinez’s solid bronze golfing statue.
With a quick and unexpected hit, Dillon was out for the count, slumping against the couch and bouncing onto the floor. The two girls left on the couch screamed. Soup dropped to his knees in an almost revent way. Some said they thought he would start sobbing, crying and demanding help and aid. No one expected him to keep swinging. He gripped the statue and plunged it down again and again, his movements like painting: up, down, up down, side to side, side to side. Each blow made a sickening sound. His face was slick with blood. Testimonies say that he had the worst grin on his face, of pure bliss. Others say they swore his eyes rolled back.
By the time the cops had arrived, Dillon Johnson’s body was already cooling. They arrested Soup without hesitation. He sat on the couch, awaiting their arrival. He said nothing to protest. The trial was a couple months later. There was plenty of testimonies, some stories more exaggerated than others, but the expected result was that Campbell John Frankinson III was guilty. He didn’t plead insanity or self defense. He was quite quiet through it all. The only defender of his was his best friend Jillian, who shared her story and caused a hush among the spectators.
Mrs. Frankinson cried when her son went to jail, but Jillian was there to hold her.
Jillian visited Soup as often as she could, but when she moved out of town after graduation, she made sure to at least visit in person for their Friendship Anniversary on April 5th. Jared lived in town and stopped by at least bi-monthly too. Mrs. Frankinson visited every week, sometimes joined by Jane, until she died of cancer in late 2016. The only day he was released from prison was for her funeral.
“Why did you do it?” Jillian asked one day. She was quiet, hushed, like the guards on duty might intrude on her truth. It was a warm April day, almost ten years after the murder. Soup shrugged from across the table.
“Dunno, wanted to protect you. Wanted him to shut up.”
Jillian was silent. She was happy now, he could see it in her eyes. She was sad on the anniversary of Dillon’s death, but she prevailed. She had two kids at home and a husband who loved her.
“Do you regret it?”
“No,” he said, “not at all.”